Aluminum Foil in the Oven: What Happens When Lemon, Tomato or Salt Is in the Dish

UAOrganic
7 min read

Salmon wrapped in foil, 40 minutes at 428 °F (220 °C). Without a marinade the researchers found anywhere from zero to 0.54 mg of aluminum per kilogram. With a marinade of lemon juice, salt and garlic it was 8 to 21 mg per kilogram. Same fish, same oven, same foil; only the marinade differed. That is the result of a 2019 Czech experiment, and it explains why aluminum foil gets called both “perfectly safe” and “poison.”

Below are three things: what moves into food and when, what limits exist for aluminum and how much of them one dinner uses, and what follows for the kitchen.

What the experiment showed: fish with and without marinade

Researchers at the University of Veterinary and Pharmaceutical Sciences Brno wrapped 11 foods in five different store-bought foils and baked them for 40 minutes at 428 °F (220 °C). Each food was tested plain and marinated. For fish the marinade contained olive oil, salt, black pepper, garlic and lemon juice. Aluminum was measured in the whole homogenized portion, in mg per kilogram of fresh weight.

FishPlain, mg/kgLemon marinade, mg/kg
Salmon0-0.547.95-21.00
Mackerel0-1.144.56-13.42

The range spans the five foils; each one gave its own result. As a control, the same fish with the same marinade was baked in a glass dish. No aluminum was found in either the salmon or the mackerel (0.00 mg/kg).

The authors themselves point out two caveats. First, acid is not acting alone. The marinade also added salt (262 mg per 100 g in plain salmon versus 647 with the marinade), while the average pH of the portion fell only from 5.72 to 5.44. The experiment cannot separate lemon from salt, and BfR (the German Federal Institute for Risk Assessment) names both factors.

Second, strong acid guarantees nothing. A tomato at pH 3.7 wrapped in foil reached only 0.37 mg/kg (raw, it had 0.08). The authors attribute such differences to a barrier of skin: marinated duck with skin picked up half as much as duck without it (22.8 versus 45.2 mg/kg for the worst foils). So what matters is whether the foil touches cut flesh soaked in brine or juice.

A second experiment: an ordinary oven at 356 °F

A group at the University of Milan (Fermo et al., 2020) baked 3.5 oz (100 g) portions of beef, chicken and fish for one hour at 356 °F (180 °C) in three ways: in a Pyrex dish, in foil with no seasoning, and in foil with seasoning (oil, salt and lemon for chicken and fish, oil and salt for beef). The foil was thin, about 20 micrometers.

  • In Pyrex, no sample had detectable aluminum: all were below the method’s detection limit.
  • In foil, the maximum was 42 mg/kg for fish and 40 mg/kg for chicken, both seasoned.
  • Beef peaked at 40 mg/kg without seasoning. The authors suspect fat and organic acids in the meat, but say themselves that more replicates are needed.

Under an electron microscope new foil was smooth, while the side that touched the meat was pitted with holes 100-150 micrometers across. With seasoning, the holes were somewhat larger and more numerous. That is the visible trace of where the aluminum comes from.

What limits exist for aluminum

Body and yearValueBasis
EFSA, 2008Tolerable weekly intake (TWI) of 1 mg per kg body weight per weekCombined evidence from mice, rats and dogs: neurotoxicity, testes, embryo toxicity, nervous system development. NOAELs for the different effects from 10 to 100 mg/kg per day
JECFA (FAO/WHO), 2011Provisional TWI of 2 mg/kg per week; the earlier 1 mg/kg was withdrawnNOAEL of 30 mg/kg per day and a safety factor of 100
Council of Europe, 2013Recommended release limit for metals and alloys of 5 mg per kg of foodA recommendation, not a binding rule. It is for testing materials, not for a finished dish

Sources: the 2008 EFSA opinion, the summary of the 74th JECFA meeting and the BfR FAQ. For a 154 lb (70 kg) adult the EFSA TWI is 70 mg per week, for a 33 lb (15 kg) child it is 15 mg (this is how Stahl et al., 2017 calculate it).

It matters how much aluminum we already get. EFSA put average adult intake from food and water at 0.2-1.5 mg/kg per week, and up to 2.3 for highly exposed consumers, and concluded the TWI is “likely to be exceeded in a significant part of the European population.” Toddlers get the most per kilogram of body weight: up to 2.3 mg/kg per week at age 1.5-4.5 (97.5th percentile). BfR later recalculated and says most of the population, especially teens and adults, already consume about half the TWI from food, while most people do not reach the JECFA figure of 2 mg/kg. So two agencies answer “is that a lot?” differently, which is why both numbers are given here.

How much aluminum one serving gives

Here is my calculation for a 3.5 oz (100 g) serving from the numbers of both experiments. It is total aluminum in the dish, not what gets absorbed, but the TWI is also counted on intake.

Dish in foilAluminum per servingShare of adult TWI (70 mg)Share of 33 lb child TWI (15 mg)
Plain salmon, up to 0.54 mg/kg0.05 mgunder 0.1%0.4%
Salmon with lemon marinade, up to 21 mg/kg2.1 mg3%14%
Chicken with oil, salt and lemon, up to 40 mg/kg4.0 mg6%27%

One such dinner does not come near the limit. But the limit is weekly, and food already supplies about half of it. If lemon fish or chicken in foil is on the menu three times a week, that is 6-12 mg, or 9-17% of an adult’s weekly limit. For a 33 lb (15 kg) child that is 6.3-12 mg of 15, or 42-80% of the limit. That is why BfR’s advice targets the habit, and one meal falls outside it.

Here the sources disagree. The introduction of Fermo et al. states that chronic aluminum intake causes Alzheimer’s disease. The review by Stahl et al. (authors from the Hessian State Laboratory) is more careful: a direct link to aluminum has been shown only for dialysis encephalopathy, osteomalacia, anemia and lung aluminosis, while for Alzheimer’s disease and breast cancer it is only suggested.

For the kitchen this changes nothing. BfR points out that in healthy people the kidneys excrete most absorbed aluminum, while in chronic kidney failure it accumulates. So people with kidney problems and families with small children are better off skipping foil with acidic and salty food.

What to do in the kitchen

Salmon with lemon and rosemary baked in a parchment envelope in a glass dish
  • Do not wrap acidic or salty food in foil. BfR names apples, tomatoes, rhubarb, salted herring, marinated fish and cheese. They should not be baked, heated or stored in foil. EFSA names the same cases: apple puree, rhubarb, tomato puree, salted herring.
  • Use glass, ceramic, stainless steel or baking parchment. Glass gave zero in both experiments. For baking in an envelope, parchment (Fermo recommends it in place of foil) works the same way foil does.
  • Salt and squeeze the lemon after baking. BfR gives this advice for grilling: season meat once it is cooked.
  • Grilling is a separate case. BfR considers a tray or foil on the grill justified, because it keeps fat from dripping onto the coals and forming carcinogenic PAHs. In that case at least do not salt the meat in advance, and better still use a stainless steel or ceramic tray.
  • The side of the foil does not matter. The authors of the Brno experiment write that the dull or shiny side has no effect on aluminum release, citing earlier work.

For dry, neutral foods (sugar, starch, chocolate, tea) the older studies cited by the Brno authors found release that could be neglected. Besides, aluminum reaches food by other routes too: plenty is in spices, tea and cocoa. For what else does not belong in the fridge and in what packaging, see the article on the never-refrigerate list, and for another metal that is regulated in greens, the one on cadmium in leafy greens.

Aluminum foil: the short version

  • By itself aluminum moves into food only weakly. In Brno salmon without marinade in foil reached up to 0.54 mg/kg, and in Milan nothing was detected in Pyrex.
  • A lemon marinade with salt raises that to 8-21 mg/kg in salmon and up to 40 mg/kg in chicken. The experiment does not separate lemon from salt.
  • EFSA: TWI of 1 mg/kg per week (2008). JECFA: 2 mg/kg (2011). One serving of such a dish gives 3-6% of an adult’s weekly limit and 14-27% for a 33 lb child.
  • BfR advises against wrapping acidic and salty food in foil and against heating or storing it that way. Glass, ceramic, stainless steel, parchment and seasoning after baking remove the problem.
Share:

Article author

UAOrganic

The UAOrganic team - agronomists, nutritionists, and organic farming specialists with over 10 years of hands-on experience. We grow microgreens and organic crops, test agronomic methods, and verify facts against scientific sources. Our content meets EU organic certification standards and helps farmers, restaurants, and conscious consumers make informed decisions.