There are three ways to grow green onions without soil, and the numbers behind them differ. Root ends from a store bunch in a glass of water give a few more cuttings for the kitchen. Onion bulbs forced for greens push their first leaves on day 4 or 5 and are ready in 13 to 22 days. Bunching onions from seed in a hydroponic channel reach market size in 48 days and then regrow after cutting for years.
Below are the three methods in turn: what each one gives, where it stops, and which nutrient settings have been tested. At the end, what makes sense to sell and what is only worth it for your own kitchen. How passive water culture works is covered in our wiki on the Kratky method, so we will not repeat it here.
Green onions without soil: three methods in one table
| Method | What you plant | First harvest | What limits it |
|---|---|---|---|
| Regrowing store scallions | the white root end of a bunch | when the leaves reach store length | reserves in the base, plain water has no nutrients |
| Forcing bulbs for greens | bulb onions or shallots | 13-22 days | the green yield is only 1.2-1.6 times the bulb weight |
| Bunching onions from seed | Allium fistulosum, 3 seeds per cube | 48 days from sowing | slow start, then a perennial clump |
The difference is where the mass comes from. A root end or a bulb puts stored reserves into its leaves. A bunching onion grown from seed builds everything from the solution and the light, so it starts slower but can keep growing.
Store-bought scallions: how many times they regrow

Regrowing works like this: set the white root ends in a shallow dish of water on a sunny windowsill, and new greens come out of the top. That is how University of Illinois Extension describes it. Change the water every few days and keep the roots in the water and the base above it, or the base will rot.
Nobody has measured how many times you can cut them. Blogs say two to five, without a single measurement behind it. The mechanism is clear without numbers: in plain water the plant gets no nitrogen or potassium, so every new leaf is built from the reserves in the base. When the next leaves come in thinner and paler than the last ones, the reserves are gone.
To keep a bunch going longer, move the root ends from water into nutrient solution. At that point it is an ordinary hydroponic onion plant that feeds itself. Trim any mushy roots first and rinse the bases: store scallions come with slime and soil between the layers.
Forcing onion bulbs for greens: 13-22 days and 1.2-1.6 times the planting weight
Bulbs forced for greens are planted close together, base down in a moist medium or on a grid over water, and the first leaves appear on day 4 or 5. That is what Moldovan researchers L. Chermnich and M. Simonova reported (Acta Horticulturae, vol. 17, 1971). They forced the onion cultivar Grubnenski in electrically heated hotbeds, with the soil at 64-75°F (18-24°C) and the air at 54-64°F (12-18°C).
Forcing took 20-22 days for bulbs planted in January and 13-15 days for bulbs planted in March. The authors credit better light and warmth for the speedup. They also noted that faster forcing gave a smaller yield.
The key number for anyone doing the math: in shallots, which the authors rated best for forcing, the green yield was only 1.2 to 1.6 times the weight of the planted bulbs. A pound of bulbs gives 1.2 to 1.6 pounds of greens. So the greens have to sell well above the price of the bulbs plus labor and heat, or you are better off selling the onions.
Hydroponic bunching onions from seed: solution, EC, and 48 days
Bunching onions (Allium fistulosum) grow from seed to market size in NFT channels in 48 days. In a study by Santos and colleagues (Comunicata Scientiae, 2021), the cultivar Tokio Kuro was sown three seeds per foam cube, moved into channels on day 14, and given solutions of different strength from day 25.
The solution followed the Furlani recipe at four strengths: 50, 75, 100, and 125%. From 50 to 100%, the plants grew equally well. At 125%, the plants made fewer leaves and less leaf weight. The authors calculated the highest leaf weight at 85% strength: 1.3 oz (36.5 g) per plant, 14 inches (35 cm) tall, with 14 tillers. For bunching onions, then, keep the solution a little weaker than a lettuce solution, not stronger.
A Korean study by Won and colleagues (2005) points the same way. Bunching onions in water culture were grown at EC 0.6, 1.2, 1.8, and 2.4 mS/cm. Growth was best at 1.2. The authors calculated the optimum for two cultivars at 1.68 and 1.57 mS/cm and recommend 1.2 mS/cm early and 1.6-1.7 mS/cm later. How to make sure your meter reads true is covered in our wiki on EC meter calibration.
Bunching onions handle salt poorly. In a Brazilian trial by Silva Júnior and colleagues (2019), solution EC of 9 dS/m left total fresh plant weight 40-51% lower than at 1.5 dS/m. The practical takeaway: in a recirculating system, top up and periodically replace the solution, because adding fertilizer does not remove the salts.
Bunching onions are cut for years: how to harvest so they regrow
The bunching onion is a perennial, and one clump is harvested for several years. Citing the Brazilian handbook by Filgueira (2008), Silva Júnior and colleagues give this schedule: the first cut comes 55 to 80 days after planting, when the leaves reach 8 to 16 inches (20 to 40 cm), and harvests continue for two to three years.
How productive a clump can be was shown by Polish researchers Tendaj and Mysiak (Acta Agrobotanica, 2007). In the fall they dug bunching onions from the field, trimmed the pseudostem at 1-1.5 inches (2-4 cm) or 3-4 inches (8-10 cm), and forced them in boxes in a greenhouse the next spring. The marketable yield averaged 2.8 lb per square foot (13.7 kg/m²) of box area over three years.
Two details from that work apply to any system. First, in a heated greenhouse at 61-68°F (16-20°C) forcing took 40 days on average, and in an unheated one at 43-54°F (6-12°C) it took 47 days, with no significant difference in yield. The cold-grown leaves had more vitamin C and flavonoids. Second, clumps trimmed higher, at 3-4 inches, made heavier plants, 2.9 oz versus 2.6 oz (82.5 g versus 74.3 g), though yield per square foot did not differ significantly.
Which green onions to grow for sale and which for the kitchen
- For the kitchen, a store bunch in a glass is enough. Change the water, cut, and when the leaves turn thin, move the bases into solution or toss them.
- For fast greens to sell, force bulbs: 13 to 22 days from planting. Check that the price of the greens covers the bulbs, since you only get 1.2 to 1.6 times their weight back.
- For a steady supply, grow bunching onions from seed. Expect 48 days to the first harvest, a solution at 50-100% of lettuce strength or EC 1.2-1.7 mS/cm, and repeated cuts from the same clump.
- A cool room does not hold bunching onions back: at 43-54°F the yield is about the same, just a week later.
If you want onion greens even faster but tiny, see our onion microgreens card for the cycle, seeding rate, and flavor. EC and pH targets for other crops are collected in our EC and pH table by crop.